GREAT-58 Reso 22-158 RESOLUTION 22-158, RELATING TO AUTHORIZING PROCEEDINGS IN EMINENT DOMAIN FOR THE ACQUISITION OF REAL PROPERTY LOCATED AT 5385 LOWER HONOAPIILANI ROAD (LAHAINA) (GREAT-58)
From: Andrew Isoda <druw.hagi10@gmail.com>
I support the Eminent Domain process with certain conditions: Corporation Counsel must be excluded: The County Council must secure legal advice that does not come from Corporation Counsel. Moana Lutey, John Rapacz (retired), and others are deeply conflicted and have repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the Council. This must not turn into a "Payday" for Greg Brown: The many proven layers of misrepresentations by Brown, to secure exemptions and permits that he was never entitled to, must limit the "fair market" value of the property and the public's outlay to "take" the property. Michelle Mclean has been lying to the Council! This property is in a Mixed-Use district that includes Hotels. Short-term rentals with no permits are how it's done in Napili Bay because it is zoned for that. McLean's promise that the County "will never issue a short-term rental permit to Brown" is intentionally misleading because he's not required to ask for one. I understand that the pushback from several groups of entrenched exploiters will be fierce. The Council must prepare itself for a very bumpy ride! But with your support, we can move Maui County into a new era as a modern municipality that serves the best interests of its residents, not the Fat Cats.
I support the Eminent Domain process with certain conditions:
Corporation Counsel must be excluded:
The County Council must secure legal advice that does not come from Corporation Counsel. Moana Lutey, John Rapacz (retired), and others are deeply conflicted and have repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the Council.
This must not turn into a "Payday" for Greg Brown:
The many proven layers of misrepresentations by Brown, to secure exemptions and permits that he was never entitled to, must limit the "fair market" value of the property and the public's outlay to "take" the property.
Michelle Mclean has been lying to the Council!
This property is in a Mixed-Use district that includes Hotels. Short-term rentals with no permits are how it's done in Napili Bay because it is zoned for that. McLean's promise that the County "will never issue a short-term rental permit to Brown" is intentionally misleading because he's not required to ask for one.
I understand that the pushback from several groups of entrenched exploiters will be fierce. The Council must prepare itself for a very bumpy ride! But with your support, we can move Maui County into a new era as a modern municipality that serves the best interests of its residents, not the Fat Cats.
As a resident of Napili I am extremely displeased with the inaction of our elected officials in light of Mr Brown’s ongoing , flagrant disregard for local building permit procedures, ordinances, codes, and the special “ village’ character of the Napili community.
I support Resolution 22-158 to acquire the property for public purposes. One possible use of the land is a small public park . A park would truly be an asset to our community.
Mr. Brown’s "monster house” threatens to severely damage the special “village” nature of our small community. It creates a precedent for others who would like to irresponsibly develop coastal areas of our island, especially in the Napili area.
I support the Eminent Domain process with certain conditions:
Corporation Counsel must be excluded:
The County Council must secure legal advice that does not come from Corporation Counsel. Moana Lutey, John Rapacz (retired), and others are deeply conflicted and have repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the Council.
This must not turn into a "Payday" for Greg Brown:
The many proven layers of misrepresentations by Brown, to secure exemptions and permits that he was never entitled to, must limit the "fair market" value of the property and the public's outlay to "take" the property.
Michelle Mclean has been lying to the Council!
This property is in a Mixed-Use district that includes Hotels. Short-term rentals with no permits are how it's done in Napili Bay because it is zoned for that. McLean's promise that the County "will never issue a short-term rental permit to Brown" is intentionally misleading because he's not required to ask for one.
I understand that the pushback from several groups of entrenched exploiters will be fierce. The Council must prepare itself for a very bumpy ride! But with your support, we can move Maui County into a new era as a modern municipality that serves the best interests of its residents, not the Fat Cats.
Greg Friedman
From: flo wiger <ashes3@me.com>
Sent: Monday, June 27, 2022 5:57 PM
To: County Clerk <County.Clerk@mauicounty.us>
Subject: Support for Reso 22-158
It I support the Eminent Domain process with certain conditions:
Corporation Counsel must be excluded:
The County Council must secure legal advice that does not come from Corporation Counsel. Moana Lutey, John Rapacz (retired), and others are deeply conflicted and have repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the Council.
This must not turn into a "Payday" for Greg Brown:
The many proven layers of misrepresentations by Brown, to secure exemptions and permits that he was never entitled to, must limit the "fair market" value of the property and the public's outlay to "take" the property.
Michelle Mclean has been lying to the Council!
This property is in a Mixed-Use district that includes Hotels. Short-term rentals with no permits are how it's done in Napili Bay because it is zoned for that. McLean's promise that the County "will never issue a short-term rental permit to Brown" is intentionally misleading because he's not required to ask for one.
I understand that the pushback from several groups of entrenched exploiters will be fierce. The Council must prepare itself for a very bumpy ride! But with your support, we can move Maui County into a new era as a modern municipality that serves the best interests of its residents, not the Fat Cats.
Aloha Council
Please have this ugly monster of a home torn down and fine’s placed on Greg Brown and an investigation do on all departments or affiliated people.
Mahalo
Ui’lani Kapu
As an owner of one of the studios at Napili Kai Beach Resort I am extremely frustrated with the inaction of our elected officials in light of Mr Brown’s ongoing, flagrant disregard for local building permit procedures, ordinances, codes, and the special “ village’ character of the Napili community.
I support Resolution 22-158 to acquire the property for public purposes. One possible use of the land is a small public park . A park would truly be an asset to the community.
Mr. Brown’s "monster house” threatens to severely damage the special “village” nature of our small community. It creates a precedent for others who would like to irresponsibly develop coastal areas of our island, especially in the Napili area.
I support Resolution 22-158 to acquire the property in question for public purposes. One possible use of the land is a small public park . A park would truly be an asset to our community.
Mahalo
Louis Pappas
Napili Ridge
120 Hui Road F
Apt F-12
As a frequent visitor to Napili bay since 1976 I’m appalled that the so-called Greg Brown “house” has made it this far. It’s clearly an ugly blot on the beautiful two-story treasure of Napili. If this cancer on the community is allowed to stand it will only metastasize. Greedy developers will learn how they too can manipulate county government to the detriment of the local community. Do the right thing!!!
Gary Cooper
Napili Kai shareholder
My name is Darlene Hosseinian and I live in Kihei. I am writing to state that I am in support of the resolution to require Greg Brown to tear down his illegal structure. This situation could have been avoided if county code and ordinances had been enforced. I think the county should offer restitution for this debacle and clean up all participating departments so that this does not happen again. This structure should not be allowed to proceed. Thank you, Darlene Hosseinian
Aloha Maui County Councilmembers,
I support resolution 22-158 and support using the eminent domain process for Maui County to acquire the Greg Brown property in Napili under the condition that the Council is legally advised by a source outside the Corporation Council. The Corporation Council has repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the County Council and clearly not operating with the best interests of our community.
The SMA exemptions and permits were obtained fraudulently through misinformation and exploitation at every turn. Greg Brown should not be able to financially benefit from fraud and deception. He was never entitled to the exemptions and permits so there should be limits on fair market value. This was never going to be a single family home, Greg Brown is trying to value at the market value for a hotel. Maui Residents should not bear the cost of this fraud.
Please do what is right for our community before it's too late. We are in the eleventh hour and you have the power to end this deception.
Mahalo,
Amy Stephens
Napili
From: Monica Davis <monicawdavis@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, June 27, 2022 11:33 PM
To: County Clerk <County.Clerk@mauicounty.us>
Subject: Support for Reso 22-158
I support the Eminent Domain process with certain conditions:
Corporation Counsel must be excluded:
The County Council must secure legal advice that does not come from Corporation Counsel. Moana Lutey, John Rapacz (retired), and others are deeply conflicted and have repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the Council.
This must not turn into a "Payday" for Greg Brown:
The many proven layers of misrepresentations by Brown, to secure exemptions and permits that he was never entitled to, must limit the "fair market" value of the property and the public's outlay to "take" the property.
Michelle Mclean has been lying to the Council!
This property is in a Mixed-Use district that includes Hotels. Short-term rentals with no permits are how it's done in Napili Bay because it is zoned for that. McLean's promise that the County "will never issue a short-term rental permit to Brown" is intentionally misleading because he's not required to ask for one.
I understand that the pushback from several groups of entrenched exploiters will be fierce. The Council must prepare itself for a very bumpy ride! But with your support, we can move Maui County into a new era as a modern municipality that serves the best interests of its residents, not the Fat Cats.
From: JIM VERBICK <jvneurotoxica@comcast.net>
Sent: Tuesday, June 28, 2022 2:07 AM
To: County Clerk <County.Clerk@mauicounty.us>
Subject: Support for Reso 22-158
[You don't often get email from jvneurotoxica@comcast.net. Learn why this is important at https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification ]
I support the Eminent Domain process with certain conditions:
Corporation Counsel must be excluded:
The County Council must secure legal advice that does not come from Corporation Counsel. Moana Lutey, John Rapacz (retired), and others are deeply conflicted and have repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the Council.
This must not turn into a "Payday" for Greg Brown:
The many proven layers of misrepresentations by Brown, to secure exemptions and permits that he was never entitled to, must limit the "fair market" value of the property and the public's outlay to "take" the property.
Michelle Mclean has been lying to the Council!
This property is in a Mixed-Use district that includes Hotels. Short-term rentals with no permits are how it's done in Napili Bay because it is zoned for that. McLean's promise that the County "will never issue a short-term rental permit to Brown" is intentionally misleading because he's not required to ask for one.
I understand that the pushback from several groups of entrenched exploiters will be fierce. The Council must prepare itself for a very bumpy ride! But with your support, we can move Maui County into a new era as a modern municipality that serves the best interests of its residents, not the Fat Cats.
Sent from my iPhone
From: Sue Cox <sueknitwit@aol.com>
Sent: Tuesday, June 28, 2022 3:34 AM
To: County Clerk <County.Clerk@mauicounty.us>
Subject: Support for Reso 22-158
[You don't often get email from sueknitwit@aol.com. Learn why this is important at https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification ]
Please make him take it down. I can see it looming on the beautiful view of the west Maui mountains from the napili Kai beach resort! I don’t know how Greg brown got this far!I support the Eminent Domain process with certain conditions:<BR><BR>Corporation Counsel must be excluded:<BR>The County Council must secure legal advice that does not come from Corporation Counsel. Moana Lutey, John Rapacz (retired), and others are deeply conflicted and have repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the Council.<BR><BR>This must not turn into a "Payday" for Greg Brown:<BR>The many proven layers of misrepresentations by Brown, to secure exemptions and permits that he was never entitled to, must limit the "fair market" value of the property and the public's outlay to "take" the property. <BR><BR>Michelle Mclean has been lying to the Council!<BR>This property is in a Mixed-Use district that includes Hotels. Short-term rentals with no permits are how it's done in Napili Bay because it is zoned for that. McLean's promise that the County "will never issue a short-term rental permit to Brown" is intentionally misleading because he's not required to ask for one.<BR><BR>I understand that the pushback from several groups of entrenched exploiters will be fierce. The Council must prepare itself for a very bumpy ride! But with your support, we can move Maui County into a new era as a modern municipality that serves the best interests of its residents, not the Fat Cats.<BR>
Our country is now seeing too much favoritism! Follow the law and do not let this project continue. Tear it down!
I support the Eminent Domain process with certain conditions:
Corporation Counsel must be excluded:
The County Council must secure legal advice that does not come from Corporation Counsel. Moana Lutey, John Rapacz (retired), and others are deeply conflicted and have repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the Council.
This must not turn into a "Payday" for Greg Brown:
The many proven layers of misrepresentations by Brown, to secure exemptions and permits that he was never entitled to, must limit the "fair market" value of the property and the public's outlay to "take" the property.
Michelle Mclean has been lying to the Council!
This property is in a Mixed-Use district that includes Hotels. Short-term rentals with no permits are how it's done in Napili Bay because it is zoned for that. McLean's promise that the County "will never issue a short-term rental permit to Brown" is intentionally misleading because he's not required to ask for one.
I understand that the pushback from several groups of entrenched exploiters will be fierce. The Council must prepare itself for a very bumpy ride! But with your support, we can move Maui County into a new era as a modern municipality that serves the best interests of its residents, not the Fat Cats.
As a resident, and property owner in Napili, I strongly support Resolution 22-158.
Mr. Brown has somehow been allowed to construct a building, referred to locally as, "The Monster House," which violates our local building code.
The house not only infringes on the privacy of neighbors, it is also an eyesore to our lovely beach area, and a signal to other builders that our building code is "flexible." I do not understand how this
building plan was approved, and support employing eminent domain to preserve the beauty and charm of the area.
We think the parcel would best be used as a small park, or cultural center, or even a parking lot.
Please stop "the Monster House" and preserve the beauty of the Napili area, as well as our integrity as a community.
Sincerely,
Fred & Kathy Fox
120 Hui Road F (Apt. F-13),
Lahaina, HI 96761
(owl20@sbcglobal.net)
My name is Carol Lee Kamekona and I am not a paid lobbyist.
With regard to Reso 22-158, I commend the advocacy and perseverance of resident Junya Nakoa who has diligently been keeping the Community abreast of this major eyesore and monstrosity.
Although I agree it should not be allowed to remain as intended, I am ONLY in support of the County exercising eminent domain on this property at the price of NO MORE THAN $1.00!!! You read right! NO MORE THAN ONE DOLLAR!!!
Should an appraisal be done and its value be assessed higher than $1.00 and the County approves its acquisition. I AM NOT IN SUPPORT of the County moving forward this with decision and purchasing the property.
Why should taxpayers hard earned money be used to award a greedy profiteer when this project should never have been allowed in the first place. Any individual with the County who had authority over alllowing permits, decisions and modifications to this project over its lifespan needs to be held accountable!
Mahalo for allowing me to testify on this item. Have a beautifully blessed Maui day!
I support the Eminent Domain process with certain conditions: Corporation Counsel must be excluded: The County Council must secure legal advice that does not come from Corporation Counsel. Moana Lutey, John Rapacz (retired), and others are deeply conflicted and have repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the Council. This must not turn into a "Payday" for Greg Brown: The many proven layers of misrepresentations by Brown, to secure exemptions and permits that he was never entitled to, must limit the "fair market" value of the property and the public's outlay to "take" the property. Michelle Mclean has been lying to the Council! This property is in a Mixed-Use district that includes Hotels. Short-term rentals with no permits are how it's done in Napili Bay because it is zoned for that. McLean's promise that the County "will never issue a short-term rental permit to Brown" is intentionally misleading because he's not required to ask for one. I understand that the pushback from several groups of entrenched exploiters will be fierce. The Council must prepare itself for a very bumpy ride! But with your support, we can move Maui County into a new era as a modern municipality that serves the best interests of its residents, not the Fat Cats.
Sincerely, David Casper,
5315 Lower Honoapiilani Rd. A206
Lahaina, HI.
Corporation Counsel must be excluded:
The County Council must secure legal advice that does not come from Corporation Counsel. Moana Lutey, John Rapacz (retired), and others are deeply conflicted and have repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the Council.
This must not turn into a "Payday" for Greg Brown:
The many proven layers of misrepresentations by Brown, to secure exemptions and permits that he was never entitled to, must limit the "fair market" value of the property and the public's outlay to "take" the property.
Michelle Mclean has been lying to the Council!
This property is in a Mixed-Use district that includes Hotels. Short-term rentals with no permits are how it's done in Napili Bay because it is zoned for that. McLean's promise that the County "will never issue a short-term rental permit to Brown" is intentionally misleading because he's not required to ask for one.
I understand that the pushback from several groups of entrenched exploiters will be fierce. The Council must prepare itself for a very bumpy ride! But with your support, we can move Maui County into a new era as a modern municipality that serves the best interests of its residents, not the Fat Cats.
From: Andrew Isoda <druw.hagi10@gmail.com>
I support the Eminent Domain process with certain conditions: Corporation Counsel must be excluded: The County Council must secure legal advice that does not come from Corporation Counsel. Moana Lutey, John Rapacz (retired), and others are deeply conflicted and have repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the Council. This must not turn into a "Payday" for Greg Brown: The many proven layers of misrepresentations by Brown, to secure exemptions and permits that he was never entitled to, must limit the "fair market" value of the property and the public's outlay to "take" the property. Michelle Mclean has been lying to the Council! This property is in a Mixed-Use district that includes Hotels. Short-term rentals with no permits are how it's done in Napili Bay because it is zoned for that. McLean's promise that the County "will never issue a short-term rental permit to Brown" is intentionally misleading because he's not required to ask for one. I understand that the pushback from several groups of entrenched exploiters will be fierce. The Council must prepare itself for a very bumpy ride! But with your support, we can move Maui County into a new era as a modern municipality that serves the best interests of its residents, not the Fat Cats.
I support the Eminent Domain process with certain conditions:
Corporation Counsel must be excluded:
The County Council must secure legal advice that does not come from Corporation Counsel. Moana Lutey, John Rapacz (retired), and others are deeply conflicted and have repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the Council.
This must not turn into a "Payday" for Greg Brown:
The many proven layers of misrepresentations by Brown, to secure exemptions and permits that he was never entitled to, must limit the "fair market" value of the property and the public's outlay to "take" the property.
Michelle Mclean has been lying to the Council!
This property is in a Mixed-Use district that includes Hotels. Short-term rentals with no permits are how it's done in Napili Bay because it is zoned for that. McLean's promise that the County "will never issue a short-term rental permit to Brown" is intentionally misleading because he's not required to ask for one.
I understand that the pushback from several groups of entrenched exploiters will be fierce. The Council must prepare itself for a very bumpy ride! But with your support, we can move Maui County into a new era as a modern municipality that serves the best interests of its residents, not the Fat Cats.
Aloha, Teresa Nae’ole
Dear Maui Count Clerk:
As a resident of Napili I am extremely displeased with the inaction of our elected officials in light of Mr Brown’s ongoing , flagrant disregard for local building permit procedures, ordinances, codes, and the special “ village’ character of the Napili community.
I support Resolution 22-158 to acquire the property for public purposes. One possible use of the land is a small public park . A park would truly be an asset to our community.
Mr. Brown’s "monster house” threatens to severely damage the special “village” nature of our small community. It creates a precedent for others who would like to irresponsibly develop coastal areas of our island, especially in the Napili area.
Mahalo for your attention and consideration
Joseph A. Fox
120 Hui Rd F APT. F12
Lahaina, HI 96761
ohananapili@gmail.com
I support the Eminent Domain process with certain conditions:
Corporation Counsel must be excluded:
The County Council must secure legal advice that does not come from Corporation Counsel. Moana Lutey, John Rapacz (retired), and others are deeply conflicted and have repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the Council.
This must not turn into a "Payday" for Greg Brown:
The many proven layers of misrepresentations by Brown, to secure exemptions and permits that he was never entitled to, must limit the "fair market" value of the property and the public's outlay to "take" the property.
Michelle Mclean has been lying to the Council!
This property is in a Mixed-Use district that includes Hotels. Short-term rentals with no permits are how it's done in Napili Bay because it is zoned for that. McLean's promise that the County "will never issue a short-term rental permit to Brown" is intentionally misleading because he's not required to ask for one.
I understand that the pushback from several groups of entrenched exploiters will be fierce. The Council must prepare itself for a very bumpy ride! But with your support, we can move Maui County into a new era as a modern municipality that serves the best interests of its residents, not the Fat Cats.
Greg Friedman
From: flo wiger <ashes3@me.com>
Sent: Monday, June 27, 2022 5:57 PM
To: County Clerk <County.Clerk@mauicounty.us>
Subject: Support for Reso 22-158
It I support the Eminent Domain process with certain conditions:
Corporation Counsel must be excluded:
The County Council must secure legal advice that does not come from Corporation Counsel. Moana Lutey, John Rapacz (retired), and others are deeply conflicted and have repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the Council.
This must not turn into a "Payday" for Greg Brown:
The many proven layers of misrepresentations by Brown, to secure exemptions and permits that he was never entitled to, must limit the "fair market" value of the property and the public's outlay to "take" the property.
Michelle Mclean has been lying to the Council!
This property is in a Mixed-Use district that includes Hotels. Short-term rentals with no permits are how it's done in Napili Bay because it is zoned for that. McLean's promise that the County "will never issue a short-term rental permit to Brown" is intentionally misleading because he's not required to ask for one.
I understand that the pushback from several groups of entrenched exploiters will be fierce. The Council must prepare itself for a very bumpy ride! But with your support, we can move Maui County into a new era as a modern municipality that serves the best interests of its residents, not the Fat Cats.
Aloha Council
Please have this ugly monster of a home torn down and fine’s placed on Greg Brown and an investigation do on all departments or affiliated people.
Mahalo
Ui’lani Kapu
Please see testimony attached.
Dear Maui County Clerk:
As an owner of one of the studios at Napili Kai Beach Resort I am extremely frustrated with the inaction of our elected officials in light of Mr Brown’s ongoing, flagrant disregard for local building permit procedures, ordinances, codes, and the special “ village’ character of the Napili community.
I support Resolution 22-158 to acquire the property for public purposes. One possible use of the land is a small public park . A park would truly be an asset to the community.
Mr. Brown’s "monster house” threatens to severely damage the special “village” nature of our small community. It creates a precedent for others who would like to irresponsibly develop coastal areas of our island, especially in the Napili area.
Mahalo for your attention and consideration
JoAnne Saysette
jsaysette@gmail.com
I support Resolution 22-158 to acquire the property in question for public purposes. One possible use of the land is a small public park . A park would truly be an asset to our community.
Mahalo
Louis Pappas
Napili Ridge
120 Hui Road F
Apt F-12
As a frequent visitor to Napili bay since 1976 I’m appalled that the so-called Greg Brown “house” has made it this far. It’s clearly an ugly blot on the beautiful two-story treasure of Napili. If this cancer on the community is allowed to stand it will only metastasize. Greedy developers will learn how they too can manipulate county government to the detriment of the local community. Do the right thing!!!
Gary Cooper
Napili Kai shareholder
My name is Darlene Hosseinian and I live in Kihei. I am writing to state that I am in support of the resolution to require Greg Brown to tear down his illegal structure. This situation could have been avoided if county code and ordinances had been enforced. I think the county should offer restitution for this debacle and clean up all participating departments so that this does not happen again. This structure should not be allowed to proceed. Thank you, Darlene Hosseinian
Aloha Maui County Councilmembers,
I support resolution 22-158 and support using the eminent domain process for Maui County to acquire the Greg Brown property in Napili under the condition that the Council is legally advised by a source outside the Corporation Council. The Corporation Council has repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the County Council and clearly not operating with the best interests of our community.
The SMA exemptions and permits were obtained fraudulently through misinformation and exploitation at every turn. Greg Brown should not be able to financially benefit from fraud and deception. He was never entitled to the exemptions and permits so there should be limits on fair market value. This was never going to be a single family home, Greg Brown is trying to value at the market value for a hotel. Maui Residents should not bear the cost of this fraud.
Please do what is right for our community before it's too late. We are in the eleventh hour and you have the power to end this deception.
Mahalo,
Amy Stephens
Napili
From: Monica Davis <monicawdavis@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, June 27, 2022 11:33 PM
To: County Clerk <County.Clerk@mauicounty.us>
Subject: Support for Reso 22-158
I support the Eminent Domain process with certain conditions:
Corporation Counsel must be excluded:
The County Council must secure legal advice that does not come from Corporation Counsel. Moana Lutey, John Rapacz (retired), and others are deeply conflicted and have repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the Council.
This must not turn into a "Payday" for Greg Brown:
The many proven layers of misrepresentations by Brown, to secure exemptions and permits that he was never entitled to, must limit the "fair market" value of the property and the public's outlay to "take" the property.
Michelle Mclean has been lying to the Council!
This property is in a Mixed-Use district that includes Hotels. Short-term rentals with no permits are how it's done in Napili Bay because it is zoned for that. McLean's promise that the County "will never issue a short-term rental permit to Brown" is intentionally misleading because he's not required to ask for one.
I understand that the pushback from several groups of entrenched exploiters will be fierce. The Council must prepare itself for a very bumpy ride! But with your support, we can move Maui County into a new era as a modern municipality that serves the best interests of its residents, not the Fat Cats.
From: JIM VERBICK <jvneurotoxica@comcast.net>
Sent: Tuesday, June 28, 2022 2:07 AM
To: County Clerk <County.Clerk@mauicounty.us>
Subject: Support for Reso 22-158
[You don't often get email from jvneurotoxica@comcast.net. Learn why this is important at https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification ]
I support the Eminent Domain process with certain conditions:
Corporation Counsel must be excluded:
The County Council must secure legal advice that does not come from Corporation Counsel. Moana Lutey, John Rapacz (retired), and others are deeply conflicted and have repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the Council.
This must not turn into a "Payday" for Greg Brown:
The many proven layers of misrepresentations by Brown, to secure exemptions and permits that he was never entitled to, must limit the "fair market" value of the property and the public's outlay to "take" the property.
Michelle Mclean has been lying to the Council!
This property is in a Mixed-Use district that includes Hotels. Short-term rentals with no permits are how it's done in Napili Bay because it is zoned for that. McLean's promise that the County "will never issue a short-term rental permit to Brown" is intentionally misleading because he's not required to ask for one.
I understand that the pushback from several groups of entrenched exploiters will be fierce. The Council must prepare itself for a very bumpy ride! But with your support, we can move Maui County into a new era as a modern municipality that serves the best interests of its residents, not the Fat Cats.
Sent from my iPhone
From: Sue Cox <sueknitwit@aol.com>
Sent: Tuesday, June 28, 2022 3:34 AM
To: County Clerk <County.Clerk@mauicounty.us>
Subject: Support for Reso 22-158
[You don't often get email from sueknitwit@aol.com. Learn why this is important at https://aka.ms/LearnAboutSenderIdentification ]
Please make him take it down. I can see it looming on the beautiful view of the west Maui mountains from the napili Kai beach resort! I don’t know how Greg brown got this far!I support the Eminent Domain process with certain conditions:<BR><BR>Corporation Counsel must be excluded:<BR>The County Council must secure legal advice that does not come from Corporation Counsel. Moana Lutey, John Rapacz (retired), and others are deeply conflicted and have repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the Council.<BR><BR>This must not turn into a "Payday" for Greg Brown:<BR>The many proven layers of misrepresentations by Brown, to secure exemptions and permits that he was never entitled to, must limit the "fair market" value of the property and the public's outlay to "take" the property. <BR><BR>Michelle Mclean has been lying to the Council!<BR>This property is in a Mixed-Use district that includes Hotels. Short-term rentals with no permits are how it's done in Napili Bay because it is zoned for that. McLean's promise that the County "will never issue a short-term rental permit to Brown" is intentionally misleading because he's not required to ask for one.<BR><BR>I understand that the pushback from several groups of entrenched exploiters will be fierce. The Council must prepare itself for a very bumpy ride! But with your support, we can move Maui County into a new era as a modern municipality that serves the best interests of its residents, not the Fat Cats.<BR>
Sent from my iPad
Our country is now seeing too much favoritism! Follow the law and do not let this project continue. Tear it down!
I support the Eminent Domain process with certain conditions:
Corporation Counsel must be excluded:
The County Council must secure legal advice that does not come from Corporation Counsel. Moana Lutey, John Rapacz (retired), and others are deeply conflicted and have repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the Council.
This must not turn into a "Payday" for Greg Brown:
The many proven layers of misrepresentations by Brown, to secure exemptions and permits that he was never entitled to, must limit the "fair market" value of the property and the public's outlay to "take" the property.
Michelle Mclean has been lying to the Council!
This property is in a Mixed-Use district that includes Hotels. Short-term rentals with no permits are how it's done in Napili Bay because it is zoned for that. McLean's promise that the County "will never issue a short-term rental permit to Brown" is intentionally misleading because he's not required to ask for one.
I understand that the pushback from several groups of entrenched exploiters will be fierce. The Council must prepare itself for a very bumpy ride! But with your support, we can move Maui County into a new era as a modern municipality that serves the best interests of its residents, not the Fat Cats.
Patricia C Inouye
2306 Shire Lane
Davis, CA 95616
Madam Clerk, and all concerned parties:
As a resident, and property owner in Napili, I strongly support Resolution 22-158.
Mr. Brown has somehow been allowed to construct a building, referred to locally as, "The Monster House," which violates our local building code.
The house not only infringes on the privacy of neighbors, it is also an eyesore to our lovely beach area, and a signal to other builders that our building code is "flexible." I do not understand how this
building plan was approved, and support employing eminent domain to preserve the beauty and charm of the area.
We think the parcel would best be used as a small park, or cultural center, or even a parking lot.
Please stop "the Monster House" and preserve the beauty of the Napili area, as well as our integrity as a community.
Sincerely,
Fred & Kathy Fox
120 Hui Road F (Apt. F-13),
Lahaina, HI 96761
(owl20@sbcglobal.net)
Aloha e Kathy!
My name is Carol Lee Kamekona and I am not a paid lobbyist.
With regard to Reso 22-158, I commend the advocacy and perseverance of resident Junya Nakoa who has diligently been keeping the Community abreast of this major eyesore and monstrosity.
Although I agree it should not be allowed to remain as intended, I am ONLY in support of the County exercising eminent domain on this property at the price of NO MORE THAN $1.00!!! You read right! NO MORE THAN ONE DOLLAR!!!
Should an appraisal be done and its value be assessed higher than $1.00 and the County approves its acquisition. I AM NOT IN SUPPORT of the County moving forward this with decision and purchasing the property.
Why should taxpayers hard earned money be used to award a greedy profiteer when this project should never have been allowed in the first place. Any individual with the County who had authority over alllowing permits, decisions and modifications to this project over its lifespan needs to be held accountable!
Mahalo for allowing me to testify on this item. Have a beautifully blessed Maui day!
Ke aloha nui,
Carol Lee Kamekona 💜
I support the Eminent Domain process with certain conditions: Corporation Counsel must be excluded: The County Council must secure legal advice that does not come from Corporation Counsel. Moana Lutey, John Rapacz (retired), and others are deeply conflicted and have repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the Council. This must not turn into a "Payday" for Greg Brown: The many proven layers of misrepresentations by Brown, to secure exemptions and permits that he was never entitled to, must limit the "fair market" value of the property and the public's outlay to "take" the property. Michelle Mclean has been lying to the Council! This property is in a Mixed-Use district that includes Hotels. Short-term rentals with no permits are how it's done in Napili Bay because it is zoned for that. McLean's promise that the County "will never issue a short-term rental permit to Brown" is intentionally misleading because he's not required to ask for one. I understand that the pushback from several groups of entrenched exploiters will be fierce. The Council must prepare itself for a very bumpy ride! But with your support, we can move Maui County into a new era as a modern municipality that serves the best interests of its residents, not the Fat Cats.
Sincerely, David Casper,
5315 Lower Honoapiilani Rd. A206
Lahaina, HI.
Napili Shores owner and full time Maui resident
Corporation Counsel must be excluded:
The County Council must secure legal advice that does not come from Corporation Counsel. Moana Lutey, John Rapacz (retired), and others are deeply conflicted and have repeatedly misrepresented the facts to the Council.
This must not turn into a "Payday" for Greg Brown:
The many proven layers of misrepresentations by Brown, to secure exemptions and permits that he was never entitled to, must limit the "fair market" value of the property and the public's outlay to "take" the property.
Michelle Mclean has been lying to the Council!
This property is in a Mixed-Use district that includes Hotels. Short-term rentals with no permits are how it's done in Napili Bay because it is zoned for that. McLean's promise that the County "will never issue a short-term rental permit to Brown" is intentionally misleading because he's not required to ask for one.
I understand that the pushback from several groups of entrenched exploiters will be fierce. The Council must prepare itself for a very bumpy ride! But with your support, we can move Maui County into a new era as a modern municipality that serves the best interests of its residents, not the Fat Cats.
Respectfully,
Sam Small
www.MauiCauses.org