Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Madison mcgain
Madison Mcgain
madisonmcgain@gmail.com
1055 upper ulumalu rd
Haiku, Hawaii 96708
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Keala Fung
Keala Fung
kealadancer@gmail.com
1138 Hassinger St #604
Honolulu, Hawaii 96822
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Elizabeth Leahey
elliebella4@gmail.com
1851 S Lakeshore Dr
Vestavia Hills, Alabama 35216
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. They were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Nicole Huguenin
Nicole Huguenin
nicolerhuguenin@gmail.com
162 Kukulu Pl
Kihei, Hawaii 96753
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Mikey Montoya
mikeym.girl@hotmail.com
104 Ikaika Pl
Lahaina, Hawaii 96761
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Ann Pirsch
anniepir2019@outlook.com
75 Copp Rd
Kula, Hawaii 96790
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Rowan Adara
Maui resident
Rowan Adara
rowanrose8@gmail.com
PO Box 1328
Makawao, Hawaii 96768
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
We won't go back.
Mahalo
Ian Ensign
kitdivine@gmail.com
180 Maoli Place
Paia, Hawaii 96779
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo nui,
Lauren Nelson
Lauren Nelson
laureneatyourvegetables@gmail.com
608 Loulu way
Makawao, Hawaii 96768
Deleted User
30 days ago
Aloha Councilmembers,
Mahalo for the opportunity to provide testimony on Bill 105, amending Section 19.500.110, Maui County Code, regarding nonconformities.
We support the intent of Bill 105 to facilitate the rebuilding of structures impacted by the wildfires, allowing families and businesses to recover quickly and efficiently. However, we have significant concerns about Councilmember Paltin’s amendment, which introduces unnecessary complexity and could detract from the bill's original purpose.
The amendment does not clearly specify which properties or individuals would be affected, nor how it would be enforced. This lack of clarity introduces confusion and could lead to unintended consequences. Such ambiguities risk distracting from the bill's original intent of aiding in Maui’s recovery and slowing down the rebuilding process at a time when speed is critical.
Short-term rentals have provided vital support to local families, businesses, and Maui’s economy. The Council has already commissioned an economic impact study to examine the effects of bills like this one. Just as in other cases, we should await the findings of that study before moving forward with legislation that could have wide-reaching consequences for our community. Moving too quickly without clear data risks hurting families who are already struggling to recover.
In closing, we urge the Council to strike Councilmember Paltin’s amendment and focus on passing Bill 105, which will support the rebuilding of Lahaina and ensure that local families and businesses can recover as swiftly as possible.
Mahalo for your time and consideration,
Caitlin Miller
Maui Vacation Rental Association (MVRA)
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Council-member Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster. This is not want the community wants. Why build or rebuild places (TVR’s) when local residents home are so badly needed. They are 1/2 empty hotels all along the west side in the Kaanapali area. Let the tourist stay in them… why build anything for tourist to rent? The locals need to be 1st!!! They need homes here on the west side. It’s hard enough to find employees for the jobs that need help because so many local people (families) that have be displaced or have moved.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns, which are repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing!!! Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything, and desperately needs Maui counties help.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Rhonda Ruidas
Rhonda Ruidas
rhondaruidas@gmail.com
3843 Lower Honoapiilani Rd
Lahaina, Hawaii 96761
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Kana Saita
zerogravitymaui@gmail.com
26 Iliwai Loop
Kihei, Hawaii 96753
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Debby Wyly
debby.wyly@gmail.com
39 pualu loop
Lahaina, Hawaii 96761
Housing Land Use Committee,
I am writing to support Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105. Please exclude TVRs from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions particularly in Lahaina. I was born and raised in Lahaina and lost my family home in the Lahaina fire. It is a struggle to rebuild and retain our community members when housing is so limited. By excluding the TVRs you can help support the rebuilding of the Lahaina Community. Housing is a basic human need and we need to ensure there is enough housing for Lahaina residents. This will in turn support enrollment in schools and ensure that there are enough students for school sports teams. It will help retain a strong workforce for all jobs including essential services as well as the tourism industry. We are in a unique situation with the fire and the tourism industry and we need a unique solution. Everyone wants a piece of Lahaina. Please make the decision to support our community over profit and ensure a better long term recovery outcome for Lahaina by investing in our community.
Mahalo,
Danielle Morris
Danielle Morris
dmorris479@gmail.com
320 Aulike St
Lahaina, Hawaii 96761
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo,
Healani Sanchez
Healani Sanchez
healanidee@gmail.com
478 Keanuhea Street
Kula, Hawaii 96790
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I absolutely support this bill. I work as a barber and I hear so much about people wanting more support for locals from transplants, settlers, owners and part timers.
When you have a struggling community, you have a an unhappy community and that is not productive for anyone. Locals need this for the betterment of their lives and future.
Mahalo for your time!
Lana Albright
lanajalbright@icloud.com
537 Kalaikini St
Lahaina, Hawaii 96761
While I am in complete support of Bill 105, I write in strong opposition to Council Member Paltin’s Amendment to Bill 105. Government should do everything in its power to ensure the rebuild of Lahaina happens as quickly and efficiently as possible and to allow all property owners in the Fire Zone to use their property in the same manner as they did pre-fire, including as STRs. To not allow this would cause additional hardship to those who have lost so much already. Those whose properties were destroyed or in any way affected by the wildfire have suffered enough and do not deserve to be further punished in this way. The issue of STRs warrants much more in-depth research and discussion of its ramifications to people's livelihoods and the economy in general and should not be addressed in this manner.
We oppose legislation that takes away property rights, particularly vested property rights when pushed by the big Hotel/Motel Hospitality industry trying to take advantage of a tragedy to eliminate any competition offering choices for visitors contributing to our tourism market and lobbying politicians to support their cause of greed with their possible quid pro quo deals.
This is the same maneuver used to eliminate STR's in South and West Maui which propose to take away vested property rights taking away a legal and zoning approved right that existed when they purchased their properties which in many cases were only possible by counting on STR income as part of their feasibility in their acquisition intention to hold until they retire and then utilize themselves. Their plans are proposed to be destroyed and taken away from the very entity that permitted such use at the time of acquisition and to which the buyer depended on which is why vesting laws were put in place.
This solution is no solution at all and does not pass the smell test.
This "solution" uses the tragedy of the Lahaina fire which impacted many families and instead of helping the displaced families, by eliminating STR's, they are ruining even more lives of those owning STR's taking away their income and in some cases will cause foreclosures due to the owners inability to make payments on their loans due to loss of income. Income they depend on for their livelihood. The ripple effect causing loss of income for all the employed workers on Maui supporting the associated infrastructure such as those workers providing house cleaning, maintenance and remodeling along with necessary materials to maintain a STR. This action will also cause a large tax loss to State and County budgets resulting in the need to tax the voters of Maui to make up for the tax loss. This new tax increase is not proposed, but we all know it is inevitable.
We strongly oppose all legislation that retroactively takes away the permitted uses that were legal at the time of their purchase ignoring permitted vested uses upon which they relied, placing their real estate investment at peril.
If this is the desire of the people, then initiate the zoning now making buyers aware of the allowed uses and restrictions, but do not create a retroactive law that needlessly takes away people's rights they had when they purchased their property and destroy even more lives. Treat others as you wish to be treated.
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Trevor Guernsey
43 Puamelia Place Unit 3
Lahaina HI 96761
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Madison mcgain
Madison Mcgain
madisonmcgain@gmail.com
1055 upper ulumalu rd
Haiku, Hawaii 96708
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Keala Fung
Keala Fung
kealadancer@gmail.com
1138 Hassinger St #604
Honolulu, Hawaii 96822
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Elizabeth Leahey
elliebella4@gmail.com
1851 S Lakeshore Dr
Vestavia Hills, Alabama 35216
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. They were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Nicole Huguenin
Nicole Huguenin
nicolerhuguenin@gmail.com
162 Kukulu Pl
Kihei, Hawaii 96753
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Mikey Montoya
mikeym.girl@hotmail.com
104 Ikaika Pl
Lahaina, Hawaii 96761
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Ann Pirsch
anniepir2019@outlook.com
75 Copp Rd
Kula, Hawaii 96790
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Rowan Adara
Maui resident
Rowan Adara
rowanrose8@gmail.com
PO Box 1328
Makawao, Hawaii 96768
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
We won't go back.
Mahalo
Ian Ensign
kitdivine@gmail.com
180 Maoli Place
Paia, Hawaii 96779
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo nui,
Lauren Nelson
Lauren Nelson
laureneatyourvegetables@gmail.com
608 Loulu way
Makawao, Hawaii 96768
Aloha Councilmembers,
Mahalo for the opportunity to provide testimony on Bill 105, amending Section 19.500.110, Maui County Code, regarding nonconformities.
We support the intent of Bill 105 to facilitate the rebuilding of structures impacted by the wildfires, allowing families and businesses to recover quickly and efficiently. However, we have significant concerns about Councilmember Paltin’s amendment, which introduces unnecessary complexity and could detract from the bill's original purpose.
The amendment does not clearly specify which properties or individuals would be affected, nor how it would be enforced. This lack of clarity introduces confusion and could lead to unintended consequences. Such ambiguities risk distracting from the bill's original intent of aiding in Maui’s recovery and slowing down the rebuilding process at a time when speed is critical.
Short-term rentals have provided vital support to local families, businesses, and Maui’s economy. The Council has already commissioned an economic impact study to examine the effects of bills like this one. Just as in other cases, we should await the findings of that study before moving forward with legislation that could have wide-reaching consequences for our community. Moving too quickly without clear data risks hurting families who are already struggling to recover.
In closing, we urge the Council to strike Councilmember Paltin’s amendment and focus on passing Bill 105, which will support the rebuilding of Lahaina and ensure that local families and businesses can recover as swiftly as possible.
Mahalo for your time and consideration,
Caitlin Miller
Maui Vacation Rental Association (MVRA)
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Council-member Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster. This is not want the community wants. Why build or rebuild places (TVR’s) when local residents home are so badly needed. They are 1/2 empty hotels all along the west side in the Kaanapali area. Let the tourist stay in them… why build anything for tourist to rent? The locals need to be 1st!!! They need homes here on the west side. It’s hard enough to find employees for the jobs that need help because so many local people (families) that have be displaced or have moved.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns, which are repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing!!! Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything, and desperately needs Maui counties help.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Rhonda Ruidas
Rhonda Ruidas
rhondaruidas@gmail.com
3843 Lower Honoapiilani Rd
Lahaina, Hawaii 96761
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Kana Saita
zerogravitymaui@gmail.com
26 Iliwai Loop
Kihei, Hawaii 96753
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Debby Wyly
debby.wyly@gmail.com
39 pualu loop
Lahaina, Hawaii 96761
Housing Land Use Committee,
I am writing to support Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105. Please exclude TVRs from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions particularly in Lahaina. I was born and raised in Lahaina and lost my family home in the Lahaina fire. It is a struggle to rebuild and retain our community members when housing is so limited. By excluding the TVRs you can help support the rebuilding of the Lahaina Community. Housing is a basic human need and we need to ensure there is enough housing for Lahaina residents. This will in turn support enrollment in schools and ensure that there are enough students for school sports teams. It will help retain a strong workforce for all jobs including essential services as well as the tourism industry. We are in a unique situation with the fire and the tourism industry and we need a unique solution. Everyone wants a piece of Lahaina. Please make the decision to support our community over profit and ensure a better long term recovery outcome for Lahaina by investing in our community.
Mahalo,
Danielle Morris
Danielle Morris
dmorris479@gmail.com
320 Aulike St
Lahaina, Hawaii 96761
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo,
Healani Sanchez
Healani Sanchez
healanidee@gmail.com
478 Keanuhea Street
Kula, Hawaii 96790
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I absolutely support this bill. I work as a barber and I hear so much about people wanting more support for locals from transplants, settlers, owners and part timers.
When you have a struggling community, you have a an unhappy community and that is not productive for anyone. Locals need this for the betterment of their lives and future.
Mahalo for your time!
Lana Albright
lanajalbright@icloud.com
537 Kalaikini St
Lahaina, Hawaii 96761
Chair Kama and members of the HLU Committee,
While I am in complete support of Bill 105, I write in strong opposition to Council Member Paltin’s Amendment to Bill 105. Government should do everything in its power to ensure the rebuild of Lahaina happens as quickly and efficiently as possible and to allow all property owners in the Fire Zone to use their property in the same manner as they did pre-fire, including as STRs. To not allow this would cause additional hardship to those who have lost so much already. Those whose properties were destroyed or in any way affected by the wildfire have suffered enough and do not deserve to be further punished in this way. The issue of STRs warrants much more in-depth research and discussion of its ramifications to people's livelihoods and the economy in general and should not be addressed in this manner.
We oppose legislation that takes away property rights, particularly vested property rights when pushed by the big Hotel/Motel Hospitality industry trying to take advantage of a tragedy to eliminate any competition offering choices for visitors contributing to our tourism market and lobbying politicians to support their cause of greed with their possible quid pro quo deals.
This is the same maneuver used to eliminate STR's in South and West Maui which propose to take away vested property rights taking away a legal and zoning approved right that existed when they purchased their properties which in many cases were only possible by counting on STR income as part of their feasibility in their acquisition intention to hold until they retire and then utilize themselves. Their plans are proposed to be destroyed and taken away from the very entity that permitted such use at the time of acquisition and to which the buyer depended on which is why vesting laws were put in place.
This solution is no solution at all and does not pass the smell test.
This "solution" uses the tragedy of the Lahaina fire which impacted many families and instead of helping the displaced families, by eliminating STR's, they are ruining even more lives of those owning STR's taking away their income and in some cases will cause foreclosures due to the owners inability to make payments on their loans due to loss of income. Income they depend on for their livelihood. The ripple effect causing loss of income for all the employed workers on Maui supporting the associated infrastructure such as those workers providing house cleaning, maintenance and remodeling along with necessary materials to maintain a STR. This action will also cause a large tax loss to State and County budgets resulting in the need to tax the voters of Maui to make up for the tax loss. This new tax increase is not proposed, but we all know it is inevitable.
We strongly oppose all legislation that retroactively takes away the permitted uses that were legal at the time of their purchase ignoring permitted vested uses upon which they relied, placing their real estate investment at peril.
If this is the desire of the people, then initiate the zoning now making buyers aware of the allowed uses and restrictions, but do not create a retroactive law that needlessly takes away people's rights they had when they purchased their property and destroy even more lives. Treat others as you wish to be treated.
Saddened dissapointed Owner.......
I am in support of this bill but I am opposed to Tamara Paltins amendment to this bill.
Housing Land Use Committee,
Aloha Chair and Members of the Maui County Council,
I am writing to express my strong support for Councilmember Tamara Paltin’s amendment to Bill 105, which would exclude Transient Vacation Rentals (TVRs) from resuming operations under nonconforming use provisions, particularly in areas affected by disaster.
In the aftermath of the Lahaina fires, our community has made it clear that we do not want TVRs in our neighborhoods. This message has been consistent throughout our recovery, and it’s crucial that the County listens. In the LTRP feedback presentation, eliminating short-term vacation rentals in neighborhoods was one of the top five concerns raised by residents. Housing needs, limiting oversized homes, and removing TVRs. We encourage you to listen to our community and act on these concerns. were repeatedly highlighted as urgent priorities to address West Maui's housing shortage.
Rebuilding TVRs would not only divert critical resources but also directly compete with the rebuilding of long-term housing. Workers like contractors and electricians are already in short supply, and restoring short-term rental properties will further delay the construction of affordable homes. Additionally, water allocations are already strained, and prioritizing TVRs would make it harder to meet the needs of local families.
TVRs have contributed to the displacement of local families and the rising unaffordability of housing in West Maui. By excluding them from nonconforming use, we can prioritize long-term housing and the recovery of our community. This amendment reflects the needs of the families who have lost everything.
I urge you to pass this amendment to protect the future of our neighborhoods and ensure our recovery prioritizes local residents.
Mahalo
Trevor Guernsey
43 Puamelia Place Unit 3
Lahaina HI 96761